The female judge said: "Defendant defense lawyer, do you want the witness to testify first?"

Qiao Yifu said: "Yes. I... my witness can explain clearly what happened at that time."

The female judge turned to Roland, "Are you the witness of the defendant? Your name?"

Roland said calmly: "Sir Judge, I am the witness of the defendant, my name is Roland."

The female judge smiled, "I am the judge of this court, you don't need to be called an adult."

Roland smiled and said, "I always call it that way in movies, Lord Judge."

The female judge obviously didn't want to waste time, "Okay, okay, you can do whatever you want, please tell your testimony now."

Roland said: "Yes, Lord Judge. On the sixth of this month, at around 9 o'clock in the evening, when the incident happened, I happened to drink coffee in the 'Silver Sand Lobby' cafe. I saw these two sisters enter the 'Silver Sand Lobby' cafe, and the three plaintiffs sitting opposite came in later. So, the waiter brought coffee to these two sisters first. As a result, the three plaintiffs over there started yelling, scolding the waiter for the waiter to send coffee to these two sisters first, but not to deliver it to them first. He also said that the waiter wanted to be with these two sisters or something. I don't know what it means to be together. But from their tone, it should be a swear word."

Several people in the audience started to talk, and some people burst into laughter.

The female judge knocked on the table, "Silent! Okay, witness, please continue."

Roland pointed at Xiang Yufei and Xu Yingxiang and said, "At that time, this sister was very angry, so she said the fat plaintiff. The fat plaintiff immediately wanted to beat the sister. The fat plaintiff stopped the fat plaintiff and refused to beat the sister. The sister seemed to want to protect the sister, so she pulled the sister, and the sister was about to push the sister away..."

There was another burst of laughter in the audience, and everyone's faces showed a smile.

The judge also smiled and said, "Witness Roland, don't you know these two defendants?"

Roland blinked his big eyes and said innocently: "Sorry, Lord Judge, I was almost late today, so I haven't had time to meet the two sisters yet. I don't know their names either."

The female judge pointed to the two defendants and said, "This one is Xu Yingxiang and that one is Xiang Yufei. Keep talking."

Roland said, "Thank you, judge, I know now. At that time, the fat plaintiff wanted to beat Sister Xiang, but Sister Xu pushed him away in order to protect Sister Xiang. The fat plaintiff might not stand firm and fell to the ground. Later, the tall plaintiff rushed over and wanted to beat Sister Xiang. Sister Xu pulled Sister Xiang away and pushed Sister Xiang on the chair. Sister Xu pushed her a little hard. When Sister Xiang sat on the chair, she raised her leg and kicked the tall plaintiff in the face, which kicked his face to the torn. I testified that Sister Xiang kicked her accidentally

Afterwards, the short plaintiff rushed behind Sister Xu, pulled her shoulder backward, and wanted to slap her in the face from behind. Sister Xu was not prepared, so she fell backwards, and knocked the short plaintiff down. Later, the fat plaintiff got up and wanted to smash Sister Xiang with a chair. Sister Xiang also threw a chair over. The two chairs met together, and no one hit it. The fat plaintiff still wanted to take the chair, so Sister Xu kicked him and he fell. Later, the police came and took them all away. Judge, this is the whole process I saw."

The female judge said, "Okay, it's very clear. Witness, please sit down. Defendant defense lawyer, please tell me."

Qiao Yifu stood up, smiled foolishly and nodded to Roland, then looked back at Xiang Yufei and Xu Yingxiang beside him, and then smiled at Yuan Nuofang and Jiang Liping.

Just say, "Yes, yes, judge. I...I have a few points to add to the witness's testimony just now. First, my client, Ms. Xu Yingxiang, is a security guard at Beijing Security Corporation who has been strictly assessed and certified by the public security department and has the qualifications to protect the security officer. Second, Ms. Xu Yingxiang was hired by the insurance company and served as the personal guard of another party to me, Ms. Xiang Yufei. Therefore, she has the responsibility to protect Xiang Yufei's personal safety. When someone wants to attack Ms. Xiang Yufei, she has the right to take action to protect

Guard. This is stipulated in the escort code of the Security Corporation, and she cannot violate it. Third, according to the testimony of witness Ms. Roland, my client, Ms. Xu Yingxiang, during the whole process, was just defending and never took the initiative to attack. Fourth, the cause of the incident was that the plaintiff insulted my client and rushed to the table where my client was located, yelled and launched an attack. Because of the above points, I asked the judge to dismiss their unreasonable appeal. Thank you."

The female judge nodded, "Very good. Plaintiff's lawyer, do you have any different opinions on the defendant's narrative?"

The lawyer stood up again, pointed to a tall plaintiff who had been bandaged half of his face and said, "Please take a look at how serious the defendant has caused my client. Shouldn't they compensate me?"

The judge looked through the information in his hand and said: "The plaintiff's lawyer, according to the injury report provided by the Public Security Bureau, the injury on the plaintiff's face is 1.5 cm long and 0.2 cm wide, which is a minor injury. The plaintiff's lawyer, don't he have to wrap a piece of gauze that big, right?"

The plaintiff's lawyer did not give up yet, and repeated the defendant's words of various boxing and martial arts, and he also repeated them several times, so he still demanded compensation, etc. He almost repeated these words.

No matter how good the female judge has a good temper and high professional quality, he can't help it.

She reached out to stop him and said seriously: "Plaintiff's lawyer, please note that this case applies to simplified procedures and time is limited. I have understood your requests, please don't say anything more. Now, on the defendant, are you willing to compensate?"

Qiao Yifu immediately stood up and said, "Judge, we completely disagree."

The female judge asked again: "As for the plaintiff, do you agree to mediation?"

The plaintiff's lawyer stood up and said, "As long as they compensate, we will agree to mediation."

The female judge turned around and asked, "Defendant, do you agree to mediation?"

Qiao Yifu stood up again and said, "Mediation is OK, but we will never agree to any compensation!"

The female judge said: "Okay, the two sides have different opinions on mediation. This court will no longer mediate and will start the verdict directly."

At this time, the bailiff shouted: "Everyone! Stand up!"

Everyone stood up and waited for the female judge's verdict.

The female judge looked back and forth at the plaintiff and defendant and said seriously: "Plaintiff and defendant, please listen carefully. First, according to the video information provided by the public security department, the three plaintiffs did follow the defendant and followed him for a long time, following the defendant into the open-air coffee staircase of the 'Yinsha Lobby'. Second, according to the surveillance video provided by the 'Yinsha Lobby' and the investigation of this court, the fight was indeed caused by the plaintiff, insulted and attacked the defendant first. Third, the defendant never took the initiative to attack, which has been proved by the witness. Therefore, based on the above facts, this court ruled as follows: 1. The plaintiff's lawsuit request was rejected. 2. The plaintiff's medical expenses and other expenses caused shall be borne by the plaintiff himself. 3. If the plaintiff is dissatisfied, he may file a lawsuit with the first instance court within ten days. This judgment takes effect immediately. Retreat the court!"

After the female judge announced the verdict, he knocked the hammer and picked up the file, got up and walked out.

Everyone on Qiao Yifu's side immediately stood up and cheered at each other.

Xiang Yufei had always been like Yuan Nuofang and Jiang Liping, and they had already disappeared at this time, and they hugged each other with high-highs, as if they were sisters.

Xu Yingxiang was originally suspicious of Xiang Yufei, but when she saw her heartfelt happiness, she threw it to Java. Like her, she slapped everyone in high-high and cheered.

The petite Roland was extremely excited.

She rushed to the audience and shouted, "Sister Yuan, Sister Yuan, have you seen it? I just said okay, I am a key witness. Those three plaintiffs, don't want to take advantage of these two sisters!"

As she said this, she turned around and looked at Xiang Yufei and Xu Yingxiang to see how they reacted.

Yuan Nuofang was also very happy, but she still curled her lips and said, "Okay, okay, I'll see you. Tell you, Xiao Alan, you won't be allowed to do this anymore in the future!"

At this time, she became more careful with the little lawyer.

Qiao Yifu was even more excited. He looked at Roland and Yuan Nuofang again, with a silly smile on his face and said, "Today... today, thanks to Ms. Roland's testimony. They said... they were in a organized manner. They wanted to argue, but they couldn't make it. Thank you Ms. Roland."

Roland turned around, his pretty face full of surprise expressions, and looked at him and said, "Lawyer Qiao, why did you stutter a little again? I see you were talking smoothly in court just now."

Qiao Yifu smiled at her awkwardly, "Sorry, there is... a little bit, there is nothing I can do."

Roland held his hand and said, "Lawyer Qiao, let me introduce it. This is Sister Yuan and Yuan Nuofang. She is the fund manager of a securities company. This is Sister Jiang and Jiang Liping, a reporter from the Securities News."

Qiao Yifu stretched out his hand timidly, wanting to shake hands with her, but he felt a little ashamed. He couldn't stretch out one hand, and said stutteringly: "Thanks to Manager Yuan for his strong support to us."

Yuan Nuofang raised her chin and looked at him, stretched out her three fingers as if she was enjoying the light, shook her for a while, then turned to talk to Jiang Liping.

Qiao Yifu also wanted to shake hands with Jiang Liping, but he had been pulled away by Yuan Nuofang.

Xu Yingxiang walked over quietly, shook hands with Qiao Yifu, and made him grin.

She said: "Lawyer Qiao, thank you for helping us win the lawsuit."

Qiao Yifu didn't care that his hands hurt and smiled happily, "Miss Xu, no... don't be polite."

Xu Yingxiang turned to Roland again, "Thank you Miss Luo for your testimony for helping us. Otherwise, we will be in trouble."
Chapter completed!