Chapter 1370 Turn the tide

The trial and confrontation continued, and the stenographer's pen kept moving on the paper.

Defense: Please briefly describe your acquaintance.

Jin Siqi: At that time, he and I were both in the Jiuyou Palace. I was injured during the assessment. He took the initiative to take care of me, which moved me very much. Later, we passed the assessment together and entered the Tiangong Gate and always maintained a good relationship.

Defence: What was the impression of him at that time?

Jin Siqi: I have a good impression of it. I think he is kind, considerate and a good person.

The defense: You can think you had a good impression of him at that time.

Jin Siqi: Yes.

Defense: Since you have a good impression of each other, you are always vague when the defendant repeatedly makes requests for dating. Can you think that you are looking for a horse with the mentality of riding a donkey and looking for a horse while hanging the defendant's feelings while waiting for a more suitable choice?

Jin Siqi: Ah? No, I wasn't... At that time, the main reason was that I hadn't considered whether to fall in love. Because I felt... I was not worthy of him.

Defence: Why do you feel that you are not worthy of him?

Jin Siqi: How do you say this... It's just that he imagined me so well. I'm afraid that after really dating, he will find that I'm not that good and will be disappointed. Then I think if this is true, it's better not to be together at the beginning.

Defense: Everyone here is familiar with this reason. Many people often say, "You are very good, but I am not worthy of it", but their subtext is still "You are not worthy of it."

Defense: So the plaintiff's reasons are not convincing, and judging from the results of her behavior, it has not really terminated the defendant's pursuit. That is to say, although the plaintiff denies the subjectivity of "making the defendant misunderstand", her performance did cause the fact that "delays the defendant's other relationship". In this relationship, my client was in an unbalanced position with the plaintiff from the beginning.

...

【About fertility】

Defense: According to the information, the defendant has told you many times about his plan to have children, but you did not have a positive answer, right?

Jin Siqi: Well...it's right.

Defense: So are you unwilling to give birth to him or not able to give birth to him? Is it a psychological subjective reason or a physical objective reason? Please answer positively.

(Because the problem is too sharp, Jin Siqi's face is obviously stiff.)

Jin Siqi: This, the latter...

Defence: Please answer my question positively.

Jin Siqi: It’s...physical reasons.

Defence: Let’s confirm again, that is to say, you are unable to have children, that’s right.

Defense: Is it a congenital or acquired reason?

Jin Siqi:...This question is about privacy, can I not answer it?

Defence: Yes.

Defense: The specific reason is that you never explained it to the defendant before he confessed in public, right?

Jin Siqi: Yes.

Defense: Dear county magistrate, this one in my hand is the test form for the plaintiff to perform surgery in a small clinic many years ago. The examination data at that time showed that the plaintiff...

(The defense recitation test form)

Defense:...To sum up, the plaintiff had had sex with more than one man, and it was the operation that caused her infertility. But the plaintiff concealed all this from the defendant, which was confirmed by the plaintiff in person just now. She had been deliberately doing things to the defendant for a long time and was maliciously deceiving him.

Defense: Dear county magistrate, my client was born in a relatively traditional family. As the saying goes, "There are three kinds of unfilial piety, and no descendants are the greatest." It is completely reasonable for him to have a child of his own. But after he tried hard to prepare a grand confession ceremony for the plaintiff, he heard about the plaintiff for the first time, and even outsiders felt a bad past. As the defendant, as the client, it was normal for him to lose control of his emotions and even speak some extreme words.

The defense: It was the plaintiff's concealment that led to a comedy becoming a farce. However, as the initiator, the plaintiff not only did not feel guilty, but also regarded himself as a victim online, mobilizing a group of netizens who did not know the truth, and long-term moral strife against the defendant, causing huge mental harm to the defendant.

(The defense read some of the curse private messages received by the defendant)

Defense: We believe that the plaintiff's performance in the whole matter seriously infringes the defendant's right to reputation, and we will reserve the right to pursue the matter.

...

【About Beating】

Defence: Under what circumstances did the defendant propose to conduct a compulsory contest with you?

Jin Siqi: At that time, I wanted to return the gifts to him. I returned all the things he gave me, and some of the things that had been eaten and used, so I returned them to him in the form of transfer. I really haven't greedy for his money.

Defense: Have the defendant asked you to return the gift?

Jin Siqi: No, he never said it.

Defense: So is it your personal behavior to return the gift?

Jin Siqi: Well... because I think since I'm going to break up, it's better to break it cleanly. I think this should be the case.

Defense: We can see that whether it is in the confession video of Tiangongmen or the subsequent online communication between the defendant and the plaintiff, the defendant never said the word "breakup" to the plaintiff in person.

Defense: The defendant loved the plaintiff deeply, but suddenly learned that the plaintiff could not have children, and he was hit hard and it took some time to calm down. At this time, the plaintiff first said "You can stop the loss in time" and returned the gift afterward to stimulate him. At this time, the defendant did not actually make up his mind to break up, but the plaintiff's intention to separate from him made the defendant suspicious, guessing that the plaintiff had never cared about himself?

Defense: Moreover, in the conversation with the plaintiff just now, she used quite a lot of "I think" and "I think". It can be seen that the plaintiff is a person with a strong subjective consciousness. She often uses her own take for granted to a certain thing. So can we reasonably infer that even the plaintiff's accusation against the defendant is actually a misunderstanding caused by her take for granted?

...

【About PK TV】

Defense: The place where the defendant finally "beats" you was on the PK station at Tiangong Gate, right?

Jin Siqi: Yes.

Defence: What kind of nature is PK TV? Please explain it to you.

Jin Siqi: It is a fairer arena... It is because the Tiangong Gate originally prohibited students from fighting privately, but students can freely initiate PK and use certain points to bet. When fighting on the PK stage, the winner can get the loser's bet points. If it is a forced PK, all points will be used by default.

Defence: In other words, fighting on the PK stage is not a violation, right?

Jin Siqi: Yes. But... no, but I had lost the ability to resist at that time. Meng Zhao still didn't stop and continued to hurt me. This is no longer a normal PK. He is venting his personal anger. It can be seen from the live video.

Defence: How to prove that you have lost the ability to resist?

Defense: How to prove that your behavior at that time was not a trick. Maybe you just wanted to confuse the defendant and take the opportunity to fight back?

Jin Siqi:...

Defense: The plaintiff still doesn't know how to prove himself. The defendant had just been criticized online and was returned to the gift. He could not think calmly, so he wanted to continue the PK. The PK itself was a legitimate act admitted by the plaintiff in person. So, the defendant did a legitimate thing on a legitimate occasion. What reason does he have to be held legally responsible?

Defense: In both parties' statements just now, the plaintiff and the defendant's mother both praised the defendant in unison, saying that he was kind, filial and considerate. The positions of both parties were completely opposite and there was no possibility of collusion. Therefore, the image of the defendant they described can be considered to be more real and credible. How could a person who is unanimously recognized as kind and gentle to commit intentional harm to his ex-girlfriend who had just broken up?

Defense: The most important point is that both parties are spiritual practitioners. According to the Criminal Law, conflicts between spiritual practitioners are not suitable for the law of ordinary people. The plaintiff's accusations are completely nonsense.

Defence: My speech is over.

...

Later, when Meng Zhao was questioned, he changed his previous warm personality and answered with great confidence, obviously he was prepared.

Judging from the performance of both parties, even if people do feel more sympathetic to the victim, Jin Siqi is too cowardly. She can be ignored by anything reasonable. The defense presses forward step by step, and I am afraid that the next judgment will indeed be beneficial to Meng Zhao.

Then, several witnesses from both sides came to the court. Meng Zhao's arrogance continued to rise, and Meng's mother's face was already full of joy.

Now sitting in the witness seat is Jian Zhiheng.

Defense: The defendant wanted to plan a confession ceremony for the plaintiff and reminded his teammates to keep the plaintiff confidential in order to give the plaintiff a surprise. You are aware of this throughout the process and helped him arrange the venue, right?

Jian Zhiheng: Yes, because we all thought Meng Zhaoren was good at that time, and thought Siqi would be very happy to be with him. If you can, please help me.

(Showing joy in the debate.)

Defence: So you all think that the defendant is a worthy friend?

Jian Zhiheng: At the beginning, it was.

Jian Zhiheng: Who knew that we worked hard to help him arrange it for a long time, and he confessed successfully, but in the end he turned against us with a disagreement! It made us a group of people embarrassed to eat the cake. I think he caused harm to our friends and should compensate us for the mental damage!

Defense:... Everything has its source. We have said just now that the defendant's emotional out of control is because he faces the plaintiff's deception for the first time. To make up for his mental loss, you should go to the plaintiff-

Jian Zhiheng: You are right! Then let me say this, please hear if there is any reason. The defendant is a perpetrator with full cognitive ability. He messed up the confession ceremony. This is his own behavior. The Tiangong Gate broadcast the process to the world. The Tiangong Gate was so angry that he came to condemn him spontaneously. In other words, the source of the infringement of reputation rights to the defendant is mainly himself, Tiangong Gate, and netizens, and what the plaintiff did was just to make his confession fail.

Jian Zhiheng: As a legal citizen, the plaintiff has the right to choose a relationship freely. As you said just now, the defendant confessed in public and she was not aware of it in advance. Even if he directly refused to confess to the party, it was her freedom, right? The defendant should have prepared both success and failure before planning the confession. He would not force a girl who doesn't like her to date. After all, he is a "kind and considerate" person in your mouth.

Jian Zhiheng: So, if you want to recover the loss of reputation rights for your party, I suggest you to directly report to the Tiangong Gate and the majority of netizens.

Defence:...

Jian Zhiheng: Also, you just said that your client beat the plaintiff on the PK stage because he did a completely legitimate act when he was emotionally out of control, right?

Jian Zhiheng: Since your behavior is legitimate, I will ask you with your question, how do you prove that his emotions were out of control at that time? Whether he was out of control or hitting someone reasonably, you have to choose one, and you can't take both sides, right?

Jian Zhiheng: Then maybe let’s assume first that even if the defendant is emotionally out of control, he will still remember the rules of the Tiangong Gate. So since you gave him a reason to lose control, just because the plaintiff returned the gift, even such a small thing will make him lose control. Does it mean that he has obvious personality defects? Perhaps he has caused more harm to the plaintiff during the process of getting along, and the plaintiff has a magnanimous attitude and has not accused one by one?

Jian Zhiheng: Sorry, you have made a lot of "reasonable inferences" just now, and I learned them from you. Imagination is the source of human progress.

Many people couldn't help laughing when the originally serious court came here.

This kid's mouth is too damaged... He is obviously not a professional lawyer, but he is so good at catching other people's loopholes. A few words are ridiculous and sarcastic, both spicy and humorous.

They also saw that the defense lawyer was very good at digging holes for the other party in his words. If he answered according to his words, he would be taken into the ditch. Jin Siqi suffered such a loss just now. But now Jian Zhiheng cleverly jumped out, instead of accepting his routine, but instead set up a routine to respond to him. He actually easily refuted most of the defense words he had carefully prepared in the early stage.

Then, Jian Zhiheng carefully helped the microphone in front of him, turned to the defense lawyer, and said with a deep meaning:

"Don't always humiliate the victim. You are now a famous lawyer, and it's time to change the defense route. Otherwise, it would be boring to play too much of the same trick. I'm afraid that your client will be dissatisfied. What do you think?"

He had fought with this man in the Yin Qiao case. Maybe he no longer remembered it... At that time, he wanted to shout loudly about his nonsense more than once. But in the end, the county magistrate accepted his defense statement.

That breath back then... Jian Zhiheng has been enduring until today. Now, seeing the other party being refuted to the point of being speechless by himself, he finally felt that he seemed to have a small sigh of relief for Yin Qiao.
Chapter completed!