Font
Large
Medium
Small
Night
Prev Index    Favorite NextPage

Chapter 132 The judgment is determined and the first instance judgment is overturned.(1/3)

 Soon...

Since the adjournment was announced, an hour has passed in a hurry.

With all the clerks standing up.

Members of the collegial panel walked into the hearing stage again.

During the adjournment stage, Wang Jianjun has finished sorting out the case.

And the trial and general judgment have been determined.

Sitting on the presiding judge's seat, Wang Jianjun looked around the courtroom and spoke slowly:

"Currently, the defense of Lin Haoxue's second-instance trial has been roughly completed."

"Prosecutor, could you please provide the complete process of the original dn inspection report...?"

Faced with Wang Jianjun's question, Yan Xiang was silent for a few seconds, wondering whether he should submit it.

Because once submitted...

Then it may cause doubts because of this submission process.

But if you don’t submit it...then there is no possibility of the case being overturned.

If the court finds that the law enforcement party was negligent...

So the influence on them is too great...

Faced with this situation, Yan Shang didn't know what to choose for a while.

After hesitating for tens of seconds.

At this time, Wang Jianjun noticed Yan Xiang's hesitation and continued to ask.

However, the tone of this inquiry was much more serious than the last time.

"The accused, please answer the questions."

Faced with Wang Jianjun's inquiry, Yan Xiang thought of a clever idea and passed the blame.

"Presiding Judge."

"As for the presiding judge's question, I have no in-depth understanding of the DN inspection process and cannot give a reply in court..."

"Presiding judge, we apply to hand over relevant materials and evidence after the trial."

Wang Jianjun:???

How did you say this...?

Submit evidence after court?

Don’t you know that there is a certain time limit for submitting evidence in court?

Besides...

You think you can’t see this little trick, I’ve been the presiding judge for so many years, don’t you think I can...?

Wang Jianjun's expression was calm, and he knew what Yan Xiang was thinking...

It's just that he plans to use this argument to show that he has evidence and corresponding clues, so that he can take this into consideration when making his own judgment.

But...

Wang Jianjun still said the same thing, judge how you should be judged....

The evidence we need to look at is the evidence in court. What’s the point of not looking at other evidence?

Even if he knew it, he couldn't judge the authenticity of the evidence, so it was equivalent to saying that Yan Xiang was playing a trick.

Wang Jianjun doesn't like this little cleverness too much.

After frowning slightly, he banged the gavel.

Boom!

"Since the accused cannot provide evidence in court, according to the court trial rules, the evidence from legal sources cannot be verified, that is, the original dn test report is determined to be invalid evidence."

Boom!

"Does the accused have any comments...?"

When he heard the verdict, Yan Xiang was stunned for a moment.

This...is the verdict...?

"Presiding judge, we have objections... We think this judgment is unreasonable. Our dn appraisal report is true, and we have proposed to submit corresponding process evidence after the court. Why should we judge our test report?

Is it invalid evidence…?”

After hearing what Yan Xiang said, Wang Jianjun didn't want to give any face to him.

Don’t you know why the dn test report is judged to be invalid evidence?

However, Wang Jianjun, as the presiding judge, still gave an explanation.

"According to Article 52 of the Criminal Procedure Law, the understanding and application of evidence collected in accordance with the law."

"The litigant has questioned the source of your evidence, and there is a factual basis. You cannot prove the legality of the source of the evidence in court. Based on the above, it is determined that your evidence is invalid evidence."

"If the accused has any factual basis that is inconsistent or believes that the judgment does not comply with any law, he can raise it in court, and the court can adopt it if it deems it reasonable."

"The accused has objections to the above determination. Now please state the accused's rebuttal."

Yan Xiangshang:…..

Submit a counter-argument…?

How to state this...

Yan Xiangshang rubbed his eyebrows, realizing that what he just said was too impulsive and left a bad impression on the presiding judge.

It is judged that the dn test report is invalid. How to say this judgment...

From the subjective point of view of the presiding judge, it can be judged invalid, or of course it can be judged valid.

After all...

dn test report This report is true.

Regardless of whether it is forgery or not, the other party cannot produce strong evidence to prove it...

Although, the other party proved the source of the blood marks on his body.

However, Lin Haoxue’s dn did remain in the victim’s fingernails.

There is no doubt about this, and this is what the other party needs to refute.

This dn can come from other sources. Of course, if it is identified based on this, then the facts identified as blood stains in the first trial will not be consistent.

But this is not the most important. The most important thing is that Lin Haoxue’s dn remains in the victim’s fingernails. This is the factual basis.

If the other party cannot prove it with strong facts.

This depends on the presiding judge's preference for the dn report...

Therefore, he used a common trick to avoid this problem.

But I didn’t expect that… I would get myself into a trap…

Wang Jianjun: Don’t show off your little thoughts.

I have tried so many big cases, and I have seen your kind a lot... Is there something wrong with you?

Reasonable and legal, no problems!

Wang Jianjun will severely punish such clever people!

On the judgment stand.

Seeing Yan Xiangshang not speaking, Wang Jianjun's expression was dull and he continued to ask:

"Can the accused provide factual basis to prove that the collegial panel has problems with this judgment?"

Phew…

Yan sighed: "President, we can't. We have no objections to the collegial panel's decision."

Dong Dong Dong!

Wang Jianjun banged the gavel and spoke:

"The prosecution's lawyer has no objections, so why did he raise a question just now...?"

Boom!

"The prosecution's lawyer disrupted and interfered with the progress of the trial process. Warn once!"

"Lawyer for the prosecution, does he have any objection to this punishment?"

Yan Xiang had trouble speaking out, and this was a clear punishment for him.

But it is reasonable and well-founded, is he angry?
To be continued...
Prev Index    Favorite NextPage