Chapter 82 Judgment: Penguin Plagiarism!(1/2)
After Cao Liqiang watched the trial evidence submitted by Su Bai, he handed it over to Chen Chao of the defendant.
After reading the trial evidence submitted by Su Bai, Chen Chao immediately spoke:
"President, these passers-by's evaluation of the two games does not have any legal effect. I apply to reject it."
Of course Cao Liqiang knew this, and of course, he knew even better why Su Bai had given these to him.
I have to say that Su Bai’s goal was achieved.
He serves as the vice president of Beishan High Court and has done some research on authorship and copyright.
After reading the evidence submitted by both parties, I had a rough judgment on the verdict.
However, the specific situation still needs to be determined through the defense in court.
You should know that Penguin’s winning rate in infringement cases in Nanshan is almost 100%.
It’s because Penguin’s legal affairs can turn black into white and white into purple.
He did not expect that at today's court hearing, Su Bai actually won the defense with Penguin Legal.
Isn't this equivalent to pressing down the little penguin's head?
Cao Liqiang glanced at Su Bai slightly, but he didn't have any bad feelings in his heart, and he even had some appreciation.
Dong Dong Dong!
Cao Liqiang banged the gavel: "The application is approved."
When he heard that the application was approved, Su Bai didn't feel too much in his heart. It would be best if he could pass, but he would be rejected if he didn't.
Anyway
My goal has been achieved!
This time, he stood in the atmosphere!
Chen Chao was a little happy when he saw that Su Bai's application was rejected.
But when I glanced at the plaintiff's seat and noticed the smile on the corner of Su Bai's mouth, my heart skipped a beat, and I always had a bad premonition.
But he couldn't tell where this bad premonition came from.
The judgment seat, the presiding judge's seat.
Cao Liqiang banged the gavel again and looked at the defendant's seat:
"Defendant, do you have anything to add to the plaintiff's accusation of plagiarism?"
Chen Chao also realized that the verdict of plagiarism was coming, and he felt a little nervous.
Because according to the current situation, their penguins do not have an advantage.
But... what needs to be said has been said, and there is basically nothing to add.
After realizing this situation, Chen Chao rubbed his temples and could only say helplessly:
"Presiding Judge, we have nothing more to add."
Dong dong dong.
Cao Liqiang knocked the gavel.
"Both parties have nothing to add to the plagiarism and have no objections. The judgment will be made below."
"Judgment!"
"The mini-game Happy Match produced by Penguin Holdings Co., Ltd. is highly similar to the Crazy Match produced by Nanyou Studio. The gameplay is suspected of plagiarism!"
"Factors suspected of plagiarism: Happy Match, produced by Penguin Holdings Co., Ltd., is highly similar in gameplay to Crazy Match, produced by Nanyou Studio, and this gameplay is original to Nanyou Studio."
Boom!
"Do both parties have any objections to this judgment?"
Su Bai raised the corner of his mouth slightly, "Little Penguin, aren't you awesome?
Aren’t you the ones who huff very powerfully with their little wings?
Is it okay now?
Did you break your little wings?
Tsk.
Satisfied!
Su Bai said: "President, we have no objection."
Chen Chao: "President, we have no objection,"
After the words fell.
Chen Chao frowned deeply and took a long breath, knowing that even having objections was of no use.
And then there is.
Penguin is indeed plagiarizing, and the evidence conditions are there. If he has objections, he can't produce evidence, and it will be of no use.
Just
The determination of plagiarism means that the penguin's little wings have been broken off.
The 100% winning rate is gone!!!
Chen Chao's mentality is a bit broken.
Kong Hao on the side was also slightly stunned when he heard the verdict. He did not expect that Penguin was directly judged to have plagiarized!
If such a decision is made, then the Penguin's 100% winning rate will be lost.
If they return to the Legal Department, the two of them will definitely be nailed to the pillar of shame of the Legal Department.
Legal Department Staff: In Nanshan, you still lost...?
Especially in infringement cases...
They can imagine the scene when the time comes.
Shameful!!
Chen Chao sighed deeply in his heart. The verdict of plagiarism was something that was beyond his control. It would be okay if he lost the case, but this was the second trial. It was just a verdict of plagiarism.
But
For the rest, if...we lose again, it will be over.
The pillar of shame is nailed to death...
At the plaintiff's seat.
Su Bai's expression seemed slightly relaxed.
The definition and determination of plagiarism have been completed, and the case has been won.
However, the lawsuit application regarding Little Penguin’s unfair competition has not yet been completed!
But...
The most difficult thing about this lawsuit is to determine plagiarism, because the most difficult thing to define in game plagiarism is gameplay plagiarism.
If it weren't for the fact that Nanyou Studio's gameplay is original, it would be impossible to judge Penguin for plagiarism this time.
And that’s it!
Penguin has a lot of legal knowledge, but he is too arrogant...
If he could study it carefully, then he would need to increase the difficulty by at least 30% for the presiding judge to determine Penguin plagiarism!
After the game plagiarism determination is completed.
This case has been considered successful.
But it’s still the same sentence.
At Baijun Law Firm, winning the case is just the most basic thing.
Winning the plagiarism lawsuit can only be regarded as breaking the little penguin's little wings that always flutter.
But as an adult, he wants both!
On the court, at the presiding judge's seat, Cao Liqiang struck the hammer again after concluding that Penguin Holdings Co., Ltd. had plagiarized Nanyou Studio.
Dong Dong Dong!
"The plagiarism determination against the plaintiff Fang Nanyou Studio against Penguin Holdings Co., Ltd. has been completed."
"Will the plaintiff and the defendant continue the lawsuit against the company and the defendant for unfair competition or reach a settlement?"
Su Bai took a deep breath: "President, we are willing to reach a settlement, but the conditions for our settlement are."
"First, the defendant apologizes to us and publicly apologizes for its unfair, unopen and unfair competition methods."
"Two, put our mini-game back on the shelves, spend it like crazy, and compensate us for our losses."
To be continued...