"It has been almost 60 years since our city was founded!"
Pullman stood on the middle stage with a relaxed expression. At this time, everyone in the auditorium was sweating for Pullman, because the key point of the ruling was still immunity, no matter what rhetoric and
means, it is still difficult to overcome the issue of immunity.
"The city's laws were established 40 years ago, and the family's immunity has existed since the city was founded! I said from the beginning that this dispute should not revolve around immunity! The reason why I will
Well, it’s because there are clear provisions in the immunity of the family. After any member of the family breaks the law, he does not need to bear criminal punishment, but only needs to bear financial punishment!"
"I object. This issue has been discussed in detail in the previous two lawsuits. Pullman's lawyer's remarks have seriously violated the Department of Law's regulations on not repeating issues!"
A justice struck the hammer.
"Objection valid!"
Pullman smiled and bowed.
"Lawyer Pullman, please don't repeat the issues in the past two lawsuits. We have already seen the trial materials and carefully considered them."
"Now I want to ask a new question!"
Pullman raised a finger, stood up straight, and looked at the Chen family and the legal team.
"In fact, because of the indifference of the Chen family, Ms. Wilsey suffered countless physical and mental violence from her husband Chen Liang, which ultimately led to Ms. Wilsey being unbearably humiliated and choosing to commit suicide. Presumably she was
The mental state is very bad!”
"be opposed to!"
The other party's lead lawyer stood up again.
"Please tell me the reasons for your objection! Lawyer Zheng Cheng."
The family's chief lawyer named Zheng Cheng stood up and bowed.
"Lawyer Pullman is secretly changing the concept. In fact, although the Chen family collectively lives in the manor belonging to the Chen family, there are independent families of all sizes. If indifference can lead to a person's death, then this
Society has long been dead! This is a domestic violence issue arising from the family built by Chen Liang and Wilsey. I hope Attorney Pullman will not involve other members of the Chen family! Moreover, this point of debate has already been discussed in the first session.
There is already an argument in the legal trial! So Attorney Pullman is changing the concept."
Zheng Cheng came out, directly brought up a light and shadow screen and continued.
"The logical question should be like this!"
Zheng Cheng said as he clicked on a file on the light screen. After the file was opened, he continued.
"Because Wilsey married into the Chen family and married Chen Liang, the couple had conflicts during the marriage. In the end, these conflicts could not be reconciled, which ultimately led to Wilsey's suicide! It was not caused by the so-called indifference mentioned by Pullman's lawyer.
, someone from the Chen family has indeed seen it, but the problems between husband and wife should be solved by the husband and wife themselves, rather than relying on other people in the family! For example. "
Zheng Cheng turned to the people in the auditorium and said.
"I would like to ask everyone, if you have a conflict with your partner, from verbal to physical, is it one-sided? Or is it involved on both sides?"
Pullman understood what Zheng Cheng said. He was directing everyone's thinking to the conflict between husband and wife. They each had their own opinions. Outsiders didn't know the real situation because these problems are all solved little by little in life.
Small problems pile up.
"The objection is valid! Lawyer Pullman, please raise new questions directly instead of repeating old ones!"
Pullman bowed and nodded.
"So what about the actual harm! What I want to elaborate on now is this issue. My client Jewell has been identified by a professional psychologist! It is already a third-level psychological disorder and is likely to develop into a fourth-level psychological disorder.
Abnormality will eventually turn into a mental illness that is difficult to cure!"
The five justices also began to read. On the light and shadow screen were diagnostic reports for Jewell. There were a total of 30 authoritative psychiatrists in the city.
"My client, Jewell, has begun to have mental illness, which was caused by being in a family environment like the Chen family for many years. Now there is a shadow in Jewell's heart, and he often can't sleep at night because of his mother's death. I wonder if we can continue to let him
Back at the Chen family, his father, Chen Liang, has been convicted of LV1 crime of violent injury. According to the Violence Law, he is not qualified to continue raising Jewil!"
After Pullman finished speaking, he bowed and left the center stage. At this time, the five justices were watching, and some people in the gallery were also watching.
"Defendant!"
Zheng Cheng stood on the middle stage with a smile.
"Of course, the Chen family has decided that Chen Jie's second aunt will raise him. As for Chen Liang, he will be sent to a mental illness treatment center for compulsory treatment. In the future, the Chen family will also hire professional psychological counselors in the city on a regular basis.
Provide psychological counseling for Chen Jie, so I don’t think Chen Jie should leave the Chen family.”
A satisfied smile appeared on Chen Dong's face, and Zheng Cheng added at this time.
"As for the marriage issue, the Chen family has indeed signed a marriage contract with the Angus family. We will naturally give a clear answer to the questions that Pullman's lawyer raised in the second trial!"
As he said this, Zheng Cheng immediately brought up a light and shadow screen and started talking about things in school.
"According to our investigation, Chen Jie has a very good relationship with Nia Angus, the second daughter of the Angus family. Lawyer Pullman once said in a rather sensational way that Chen Jie will make the same mistakes again and fall into misfortune.
marriage, but there is a lot of evidence that shows that men and women who had a good relationship as children have a higher probability of a happy marriage after they finally live together!"
After Zheng Cheng finished speaking, he bowed and returned to the dock.
"Adjourn the court for half an hour!"
The five judges turned and walked into the reconsideration room at the back.
Pullman was silent, and the lawyers next to him were still discussing countermeasures. Because in the last trial, public opinion overwhelmingly supported Jewell's separation from the Chen family, so the five justices were dismissed before the final trial.
jury.
This chapter is not over, please click on the next page to continue reading! Originally, if the jury was present, it would be more favorable to Pullman and the others. Now it seems that the situation is not good. The plan failed. The other party did not give themselves any chance. They died.
He clings to immunity.
Pullman originally planned to guide the other party bit by bit, bringing the matter into the issue of whether the environment is suitable for Jewell's growth, and then began to cite some children's problems that were caused by environmental problems in the past to proceed to the next stage of the debate.
, but now the first stage of the trial has ended suddenly, indicating that the five justices have now reached a preliminary conclusion on this case.
Now it is obviously unworkable. The other party has made all preparations. The implication is that it will give Jewell a good living environment and there is no need to continue the debate. The situation is terrible.
In a legal lawsuit that was fundamentally unequal because of immunity, this lawsuit ended in vain from the beginning just like last year's lawsuit involving Jewel against the entire Chen family.
The five justices also knew this, so they ended the trial and adjourned for deliberations.
Pullman looked at Jewell next to him worriedly. He should also know at this moment that this child is quite smart and there is actually no room for maneuver in this lawsuit.
It is assumed that Chen Jie wants to leave the Chen family, unless no one in the Chen family except Chen Jie has the ability to continue raising Chen Jie. But now that the other party has blocked all the places, Pullman feels that for the first time
Powerless, it's like you are clearly stronger than the opponent, but you can only let the opponent defeat the weak in the ring, and you are powerless on the sidelines.
9:21 am
The five justices are still looking at various materials over and over again. The matter must be concluded today. Although the five justices sympathize with Jewell's experience, it is unfair to mix sympathy and pity into the law.
practice.
The faces of the five people looked a little bitter. This lawsuit is related to the future of the family as a whole. If this breakthrough is opened, the law will lose its fairness and public opinion will prevail. This is not what the five people want to see, nor what they want to see.
It should be the ultimate result pursued by the law, with public opinion overriding the law.
The facts are very clear. Jewel has lost his mother and his father has been sent to a mental health center. However, this does not mean that the relatives of the Chen family and Jewel are not able to raise him, as long as someone is willing to take the responsibility.
, and the Chen family has already done everything, as well as the follow-up psychological treatment, the Chen family has also promised.
No matter how you look at this kind of thing, it is impossible for the plaintiff to win. The five people had made the decision a long time ago and would not let the Hydera case happen again. The city's situation at that time did not allow it, and the gods became the decisive one.
interfering factors.
God's orders cannot be violated. In the Hydera case, the pressure they suffered came from the gods, not the bar association, nor people from the business and political circles.
click
The window of the room opened. At this time, the five people looked towards the window. Gene was squatting at the window with a cigarette in his mouth.
"Lord Jean!"
The five people looked at Jean quietly, and stood up and bowed one after another. Jean nodded and motioned for the five of them to sit down.
"Is it the gods..."
Gene smiled and shook his head.
"No one will interfere with you this time. The last time was 6 vs. 1, in order to appease the city, so Hydera is guilty! Even if I think he is innocent, nothing can be changed, but this time is different. I believe in what you hope in your heart.
And confirm your faith in the law.”
To be continued...