The confrontation between the two sides has passed.
Zheng Yuankai nodded and said to Dai Qisui: "According to the prosecutor's opinion, the trial can now be confirmed. I don't know if the Tax and Silk Bureau has any other opinions."
This sentence is not a vain question, it is to determine whether the Tax and Silk Bureau will comply with the trial here and whether it will accept the judge's decision.
If there are other matters, always tell them clearly before the confrontation, so as to avoid quarreling.
Dai Qisui naturally understood this meaning, and immediately nodded and said: "It is already clear that the Tax and Silk Bureau has no significance for the trial of the case, and now it can be tried."
Seeing that both parties had completed the confirmation, Zheng Yuankai stopped talking nonsense and said in shock: "Okay. Then I will start the formal trial of the case. Everyone in the hall is listening to the trial and there is no need to make any noise! Okay, then Chief Dai, you will start.
Let me introduce why the Tax and Silk Bureau charged Li Junfeng two thousand taels in taxes for this transaction."
After hearing this, Dai Qisui stepped forward, faced everyone, and started talking.
"The Li family's transaction is very clear. But the tax law issues here are more complicated.
First, the Li family bought a piece of land and started construction. Now, the completed small building is for sale, that is, it is sold together with the land.
The first tax to be paid is land appreciation tax.
They bought this piece of land for 1,000 taels, and spent 3,000 taels on the construction, but there was no proof of the 3,000 taels of construction expenses.
In other words, the maximum construction amount we could estimate for him was 1,500 taels. But he sold this piece of land for 5,000 taels.
During this period, the amount increased by 2,500 taels, so for this item alone, a tax of 700 taels has to be paid."
When everyone heard this, most of them had different opinions.
Li Junfeng also frowned upon hearing this.
He did spend 3,000 taels on the construction, and the turning tiles alone were worth more than 1,000 taels, as well as artificial decoration and so on.
But unfortunately, this matter really went too far, and the people we hired at that time were all contractors. So we didn’t even leave a voucher.
Meng Zhu, who was listening in, said: "Oh, it turns out that the voucher is lost. It is true that the tax and silk department can only help you calculate the cost. But only 1,500 taels were calculated. Isn't it too little?"
Fu Xingwen said: "Brother Meng, you can't say that. To be honest, the price two years ago, even if it was calculated as 1,000 taels for him, it would be no problem. It seems that the tax department is still treating the Li family well. This is
It will increase the cost for the Li family."
After hearing this, Meng Zhu nodded and said, "That's true. But this item costs 700 taels. It's really not cheap."
Fu Xingwen said with a smile: "What's wrong with this? It's better to charge less. Otherwise, Mr. Li has earned 2,500 taels from this alone, and the tax department can ask him to collect more than 1,000 taels. As long as he
700 taels is probably a friendly price."
Dai Qisui continued: "
This second tax is mainly aimed at his transaction this time.
Li Junfeng transferred the shop, and the goods or shops also appreciated in value during the transfer, so there was a value-added tax. For a transaction of 5,000 taels.
The tax rate is about 15%. Therefore, after calculation, it is about 750 taels."
Upon hearing this price, everyone present felt their throats tighten.
This tax alone costs more than 700 taels.
Fu Xingwen said: "But having said that, this is correct. The rouge, gouache, firewood, rice, oil and salt we usually buy do not have value-added tax. It's just that if you take this thing out and calculate it separately, it is still too scary."
Meng Zhu nodded and said: "That's true. But these two items cost 1,450 taels. It seems that the Li family's 2,000 taels in taxes are really justified."
Dai Qisui continued: "This third tax is the Li family's income tax.
The Li Family Trading Company is, after all, a large local trading firm. Everyone knows this.
The Li family has earned more than 2,000 taels in total from this store over the years. When transferring the store, since they did not have a cost price for this store, we calculated the cost price for him to be 4,000 taels, so he earned another 1,000 taels.
Inside and outside, the Li family earned 3,000 taels of silver from this shop.
Calculated according to the merchant’s income tax rate of 25%, that is an income tax of 750 taels.”
As soon as this statement came out, the whole audience was shocked.
Meng Zhu said: "Another 750 taels, which is really too high. But I don't know. The Li family has still made a lot of money. Just one shop has made 3,000 taels in profit over the years."
Fu Xingwen, who was on the side, smiled and said: "This tax and silk department still takes care of the Li family."
Meng Zhu asked curiously: "How to say?"
Mr. Wang on the side sighed leisurely and said: "Only the Li family has this kind of treatment. The market price of the shop is 4,000 taels. When the Li family wanted to transfer it, I asked around and the price was just this much. But the tax and silk department said
When calculating, it is usually a little lower than the market price. So if the price calculated by the Tax and Silk Department reaches 3,000 taels, then the Li family’s income tax is estimated to be 1,000 taels. This transaction alone can collect 500 taels of income tax.”
Fu Xingwen on the side also nodded and said: "Yes, that's the truth. So, the Li family still has something. You look at the tax and silk department's calculation, but they are helping the Li family overtly and covertly."
Dai Qisui continued:
"Therefore, the total tax for the three items is: 2,200 taels of silver. Considering that the Li family is a large taxpayer, our tax department gave a discount and charged 2,000 taels of silver.
I wonder if you have any questions."
After hearing this, Mr. Wang showed a panic expression and said: "I also thought that the tax department made a mistake before. I transferred a shop, but only made 1,000 taels. Why did you ask for 2,000 taels when you first came up? It turned out to be okay.
Calculate it this way.”
Fu Xingwen said: "This is a discount given by the Tax and Silk Bureau to give the Li family face. It can be seen that there is no miscalculation."
Meng Zhu said: "Then why does the Li family still want to sue?"
Fu Xingwen said: "But any company that earns 1,000 taels but pays 2,000 taels in taxes is always uncomfortable. It is normal to sue."
After hearing this, everyone sighed. It can be seen that both sides are actually not wrong. One side is based on the tax law and is justified, and the other side is based on common sense and there is no problem.
Everyone was buzzing with discussion.
Then the buzzing gradually disappeared, and everyone turned their attention to Sun Yi to see what the lawyer hired by the Li family could say.
Dai Qisui looked at Sun Yi provocatively and thought to himself, "Young man who doesn't even have a good defense, you will be unlucky if you take on this lawsuit."
Who asked you to take this lawsuit? There is nothing you can do if you lose.
Zheng Yuankai looked at the Li family and said, "What else do you have to say about these."
Sun Yi met the eyes of everyone present and said: "Of course we have strong opinions, because of the calculations of the Tax and Silk Bureau.
It’s simply wrong!”
As soon as these words came out, everyone present looked at Sun Yi in surprise.
Sun Yi remained calm, which was not surprising, and then said to everyone present: "First of all, I want to make something clear to everyone."
Hearing this, everyone's appetite was whetted by Sun Yi, and they looked at Sun Yi with burning eyes.
But Sun Yi asked Li Junfeng confidently, "Are you a human being?"
...
You must be tired after reading this. Take a break when you are tired. If you think this book is good, please vote for it. The support of readers is the biggest motivation for me to persevere.