Chapter 217 The Law of Conservation of Pig Teammates
Now is the cross-examination and court debate. In theory, both the prosecution and the defense can speak freely.
Therefore, the judge did not stop Zhang Renjie's speech.
Just watch his performance quietly.
"I have not practiced medicine illegally! I have a certificate! It is a medical qualification certificate issued by the state!"
"The above is my name, my identity information, and a stamp!"
"I am on duty with a certificate, why do you say that I am practicing medicine illegally?
!”
Zhang Renjie was extremely excited and argued loudly.
Next to him, Chen Mengzhe had given up treatment.
Sitting on a chair, my face full of life was full of love and I didn't want to say a word.
As for Zhang Wei and Du Yansen, they watched the show all the time, and even wanted to applaud Zhang Renjie and wish him good luck.
This old boy may have been frightened by the "twenty years of imprisonment" and completely lost his mind and ignored the basic logic.
Moreover, he himself did not understand the legal provisions and did not know what the constituent elements of the crime of illegal medical practice were. He just kept screaming and complaining at the top of his voice.
This kind of behavior is actually very undesirable.
Apart from disrupting the rhythm of the defense lawyer and leaving a bad impression on the collegial panel, there is no help at all!
Instead, it will make you sink deeper and deeper in the quagmire.
As soon as Zhang Renjie finished speaking, Chen Tianci stood up and said loudly: "The crime of illegally practicing medicine refers to the act of people who have not obtained the qualification to practice medicine in a serious manner."
"And in the Supreme Court's Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Specific Application of Laws in the Trial of Criminal Cases of Illegal Medical Practice", four situations that should be considered as 'Illegal Medical Practice for People Who Have Not Acquired the Professional Qualification for Doctors'."
"The first one is to engage in medical activities without obtaining or illegal means of obtaining medical qualifications!"
"The doctor's qualification certificate of defendant Zhang Renjie was obtained through others' exams, so it should naturally be considered illegal medical practice!"
Although Chen Tianci was wearing a pair of gold-rimmed glasses and had a very elegant appearance, he was a powerful soldier when he went to court!
The sound is powerful and powerful.
He directly confronted Zhang Renjie speechlessly, not knowing how to speak.
"This...but...I..."
Chen Tianci snorted coldly and continued: "According to Article 4 of the Interpretation, illegal medical practice is the direct cause of death of the person who visited the doctor. The main reason should be determined as the "causing treatment as stipulated in Article 336, Paragraph 1 of the Criminal Law."
A person dies, a sentence of more than ten years to fixed-term imprisonment!"
"On X, X, Zhang Renjie delivered Li Xiaoyun. During the operation, Li Xiaoyun bleeded heavily. Zhang Renjie did not take the right measures and missed the best rescue time, which caused her to die on the operating table."
"In this medical accident, Zhang Renjie was the direct person responsible. His inaction and wrong actions were the main reasons for the death of the doctor!"
"About this, the judge, the prosecutor applies for witnesses to appear in court."
After obtaining the judge's consent, the witness was quickly taken to court.
She is a woman in her thirties.
"Witness, please ask your name and work unit." Chen Tianci began to ask a question.
The witness said: "My name is Zhou Ping, and I am an obstetric midwife in Aikang Hospital."
Chen Tianci continued to ask: "On X, X, Is there anything that impressed you particularly?"
Zhou Ping gritted her teeth and said slowly: "That day, a very serious medical accident occurred in our department. A mother died of severe postpartum bleeding."
Chen Tianci asked, "Why do you know so clearly?"
Zhou Ping: "Because I am the midwife for that operation."
"Can you describe in detail the situation at that time?"
"I remember, Li Xiaoyun, oh, it was the mother. She was pushed into the operating room at around 8:30 pm. Everything was going well, but just after the child was born, Li Xiaoyun suddenly bleed heavily. In this case,
The most important thing is to quickly control the bleeding, prevent shock and infection from mothers, and different methods must be taken according to different causes of bleeding. At that time, Li Xiaoyun's bleeding was very serious. We used oxytocin and filled with gauze strips and couldn't control it. At this time,
The surgery required to control the bleeding, but... but the surgeon at that time seemed to have no experience and did not take timely measures, which led to..."
"You fart! At that time, I was obviously working very hard to control bleeding and rescue the mother! Why do you say that!"
Before Zhou Ping could finish her speech, she was forcibly interrupted by a sharp voice.
"I have any grudges against you, why do you harm me like this?
!”
Zhang Renjie stared at her fiercely, as if he wanted to eat people.
"winter!"
"Defendant, it's time for the prosecutor to ask questions, don't interrupt!"
Chen Zhonghan warned him sternly, and then said to the witness: "Witness, continue to state."
"good……"
Zhou Ping swallowed and continued: "Because the surgeon did not take the right remedy measures in time, the mother suffered too much bleeding and suffered shock. Then she missed the best rescue time, and so... she died."
Chen Tianci asked: "Who is the surgeon? Is there this trial court?"
Zhou Ping raised her hand and pointed at Zhang Renjie with a pale face in the defendant dock, and shouted: "It's him! Zhang Renjie! He was the surgeon of the year."
"Okay, thank you."
Chen Tianci looked towards the judge and said, "I've finished asking."
"The defense lawyer can ask the witness questions." Chen Zhonghan said.
Chen Mengzhe breathed a sigh of relief and adjusted his mentality.
No matter what, I am Zhang Renjie's defense lawyer after all, and I still have to do what I should do.
"Witness, you are just a midwife, not an obstetrician. Why can you conclude that the surgical accident was caused by our party?"
Chen Mengzhe’s first question is extremely sharp.
Zhou Ping glanced at him and said, "You don't know what to do at first glance."
Chen Mengzhe's face turned green with just one sentence.
Zhou Ping held her head up and said loudly: "Okay, then I will tell you why, just rely on my ability and experience!"
"I am a graduate of the XX class of Angel Midwifery School, and I graduated with the top three in the same class, with rich theoretical knowledge."
"The year that happened was my fifth year in work. Before that, I had seen severe bleeding in the mother during the surgery of other doctors, and also how other doctors deal with this accident."
"In contrast, Zhang Renjie's handling is simply a mess! He doesn't look like a top student who graduated from a famous medical university, nor does he look like an obstetrician with years of experience in practicing medicine, but more like an intern who has just graduated and started working."
Chen Mengzhe frowned slightly and raised an evidence and said: "This is the investigation report of the Health Commission on the medical accident that year. The conclusion shows that it was an ordinary medical accident without human factors. The doctor and midwife involved,
Nurse and others are not responsible and exclude medical devices and other reasons."
"Witness, how do you explain this?"
"That's because Zhang Renjie paid for it!"
Zhou Ping took a deep breath and revealed another hidden story back then: "The intern doctor, nurse and midwife who participated in the operation received a big red envelope from him, so when we were under investigation by the Health Commission, we all
Speaking to him, he helped cover it up."
"After that incident passed, I often had nightmares for a long time, and I always dreamed of Li Xiaoyun. She was covered in blood, crying and shouting to me that she died unjustly."
"I've been guilty of this for many years."
"A few days ago, someone from the procuratorate came to me and asked me about the truth about that year. I felt that I could not remain silent, so I chose to stand up and tell the truth."
"Now, I feel very relaxed, and I am worthy of Li Xiaoyun's spirit in the sky."
"Zhou Ping! Don't swear! You are deliberately retaliating against me! You stinky cousin!" Zhang Renjie shouted and cursed.
Zhou Ping turned her head and looked at him, saying, "Zhang Renjie, I have been waiting for a long time this day. I have always been very surprised, why do you have such a good resume and education, but your level is so bad!"
"Now I understand, it turns out that your education is fake, and your doctor's qualification certificate is obtained by others. People like you are not worthy of being a doctor at all!"
"You are kidding about the safety of life of all pregnant women, mothers and children!"
"Bah!"
Zhou Ping was full of disgust and spat at Zhang Renjie.
"A scum like you! You should have been punished by law long ago! Fortunately, the retribution didn't come too late."
"Fuck you, you're slandering! I'm going to sue you for slander!"
Zhang Renjie cursed angrily and was about to rush up.
But it was stopped by two bailiffs.
"Winter! Winter! Winter!"
Chen Zhonghan knocked the gavel three times in a row and said in a deep voice: "Defendant! Pay attention to court discipline! If you speak rudely again, I will expel you from court!"
"Huh! Huh! Huh!"
Zhang Renjie was held on his shoulder by two bailiffs, his face flushed and he was panting.
His eyes were staring at Zhou Ping with scarlet eyes.
He gritted his teeth and said, "You stinky cousin! Wait for me when I go out!"
As soon as he said this, everyone was shocked.
Chen Mengzhe was even more angry and wanted to rush up and sew Zhang Renjie's criticism onto his mouth.
Threat witnesses in front of the judge?
This fucking zombie comes back in disappointment.
"winter!"
Chen Zhonghan beat the gavel heavily and said with a stern face: "Battleman, take the defendant down!"
"I can't go down! Why should I take me down! I don't accept it, I..."
Zhang Renjie struggled wildly and shouted.
Yet, it's all over the place.
After all, he was forcibly taken down and was detained in the detention room.
The court finally became clearer.
Seeing this scene, everyone in the dock expressed their eyes open.
Before the trial was over, the defendant was expelled from the court???
What kind of Tianxiu is this?
"Hey Jiang Bai, the defendant has been driven out. Isn't the trial impossible?" Chu Meiyan turned her face and asked in a low voice.
Jiang Baidandan said: "It actually has no impact on whether the defendant is in the court or not. If there is an agent, then continue the trial. If there is no agent, there will be a trial in absentia."
Chu Meiyan blinked, "So it's possible... Zhang Renjie is so arrogant. It seems that he hasn't been away for twenty years, right?"
"89 is not separated from ten."
While the two were talking.
Chen Mengzhe said to the judge with a dark face: "There is no problem with the defense lawyer."
Then, witness Zhou Ping retired from court.
Chen Tianci continued to provide evidence.
This time he prepared very well, with all the evidence and witnesses.
Even the members of the gang who sold Zhang Renjie fake certificates that year were taken to court to testify.
Another doctor and two nurses at Aikang Hospital also appeared in court to testify, accusing Zhang Renjie of several medical accidents, the main reason was him.
Under the joint proof of these evidence and witnesses, Zhang Renjie's several charges were almost certain and there was no room for defense.
In addition to the crime of fraud.
Among the six charges Zhang Renjie is suspected of, there is a possibility that there is no argument for fraud. Don’t even think about other charges.
Therefore, Chen Mengzhe’s initial defense idea was to admit guilt and accept punishment, apologize and compensate, and strive to get a reduction in sentence. He could make one year count, and he could make one month count, and he could make one month count.
Then try to defend the crime of fraud.
In this way, Zhang Renjie's sentence may be reduced to less than twenty years.
It’s a pity that he was disturbed by Zhang Renjie’s idiot at the beginning.
Chen Mengzhe can only bite his teeth now.
"There are two important points in the constituent elements of the crime of fraud. One is to make the victim suffer property losses."
"Although our party has faked his education and the source of the medical qualification certificate is illegal, he has actual work content in Aikang Hospital and has obtained labor remuneration from this. It is not for the purpose of illegal possession, nor has it caused Aikang Hospital to suffer property losses.
.”
"So I believe that the actions of our parties do not constitute fraud."
As soon as Chen Mengzhe finished speaking, Chen Tianci stood up and retorted: "The defendant had a problem of falsification of education and illegal source of medical qualification certificates. This is a fictitious fact, this is a deception method!"
"On the basis of this behavior, the defendant obtained salary from the hospital, which is illegal possession!"
"As for the property losses suffered by Aikang Hospital, they can be divided into two parts, one is the salary, bonus, etc. paid to the defendant, and the other part is the losses caused by the defendant's medical malpractice!"
“The total amount is as high as millions!”
"This has reached the standard of the crime of fraud that the 'extreme amount' is very huge', and the starting point of sentencing is more than ten years!"
Chen Mengzhe's face changed slightly and he hurriedly said, "Oppose, I think our party is not guilty of fraud, the reason is..."
Next came another fierce debate.
From twelve to one o'clock, the court will be adjourned for one hour, and the trial will continue in the afternoon.
The focus of the debate between the prosecution and the defense mainly revolves around whether the crime of fraud is established and whether several other crimes can be applied to commutation of sentences.
Finally, at 4:30 pm, Chen Zhonghan beat the gavel and ended the court debate.
Next, the defendant's final statement time.
Zhang Renjie was taken back to court.
The final statement is his right.
Du Yansen spoke first, and the statement was actually very simple. It was mainly to once again show that he had no intention of instigating crime and to ensure that he would be more cautious when communicating with the parties in the future to avoid similar situations.
Then there is Zhang Renjie.
After staying in the detention room for several hours, he calmed down.
Holding the statement prepared by Chen Mengzhe for him, he recited it in a trembling voice: "I... feel deeply regretful of the crime I committed, and apologize to all those who have been hurt by me..."
"I will do my best to compensate all victims for their losses..."
"I would like to ask the judge to give me a lighter sentence. I will definitely change my mind and become a new person..."
“…”
As they were talking, they all started crying.
The voice is trembling, and the person is trembling.
Unfortunately, no one felt pitiful.
They are all facing each other coldly.
A scumbag like Zhang Renjie should have been punished by law long ago.
No matter how severe the punishment he receives, he deserves it and is blamed on his own.
Some people even think that they should give him a peanut to end his sinful life.
However, this kind of wish is basically impossible to achieve.
Xia State adopted the death penalty policy of "killing less and being cautious, and killing rigorously and wrongly". Article 48, paragraph 1 of the Criminal Law also stipulates: "The death penalty is only applicable to criminals with extremely serious crimes."
Therefore, although the death penalty has not been abolished, this "glory" is really not something that anyone can enjoy.
After the statement was completed, Zhang Renjie bowed deeply to the judge and did not get up for a long time.
Jiang Bai shook his head secretly.
If you can have this attitude from the beginning, you may also reduce the sentence by several years.
Now...
It's useless anymore.
It can be said that he had completely blocked his way to reduce his sentence by himself. No matter how much he didn't save him in the later stage, it would be useless.
"winter--"
Chen Zhonghan announced an adjournment and walked out with the members of the collegial panel.
Next they have to discuss how to deal with the two defendants.
One is guilty and innocence.
One is the cap sentence.
They are all special and must be treated with caution.
For others, the half hour of the recession may have passed by in a flash and there is no feeling at all.
But for Zhang Renjie, who was suffering, it was extremely slow, and it was as fast as a year.
finally.
The court has been reopened.
"winter--"
The sound of the gavel ringing resounded in the courtroom.
Everyone suddenly became quiet.
Du Yansen swallowed quietly, and his palms were sweating.
Although he has the advantage in the court debate, he is still a little nervous as the verdict is approaching.
After all, there is a big difference between guilt and innocence.
Zhang Renjie was even more unbearable.
It seemed that I had a premonition that my legs were trembling, and I couldn't stand steadily, and I had to hold the table with my hands to barely support it.
His face was pale and covered with sweat.
The nervous heart was about to jump out of my throat.
Above the court.
Chen Zhonghan's solemn and serious voice sounded.
"The first Criminal Trial Division of the People's Court of Binjiang District, Longcheng City, has been tried for the case between Zhang Renjie and Du Yansen."
"After investigation, Du Yansen's words and deeds did not meet the constituent elements of the instigator. Zhang Renjie's act of obstructing testimony was entirely out of his own subjective malice and should not be considered as being instigated by Du Yansen..."
After Chen Zhonghan made a brief statement, he said in a deep voice: "This court believes that Du Yansen's behavior is not an instigation crime!"
"According to Article 29 of the Criminal Law and Article 15 of the Criminal Procedure Law, this court made the following judgment:"
"The procuratorate's lawsuit against Du Yansen will be rejected and he will not be held criminally responsible, but I hope Du Yansen can be cautious in his words and actions in the future to avoid another similar accident."
Hearing this, Du Yansen immediately breathed a sigh of relief.
My heart fell back into my stomach.
Zhang Wei couldn't help but raise his lips and smiled.
It is not an easy task to defeat the prosecutor in the public prosecution case and win the defense of innocence for the defendant.
The two looked at each other and smiled.
Chen Zhonghan then read out Zhang Renjie's verdict.
"After the court investigation, Zhang Renjie was suspected of six charges, all of which were clear in the criminal facts, the evidence was indeed sufficient, and there was no doubt."
"In accordance with the provisions of Article 29, Article 280, Article 284, Article 307, Article 335, and Article 336, this
The court made the following judgment:”
"The defendant Zhang Renjie was sentenced to medical malpractice, obstruction of testimony, replacement of examinations, illegal practice of medicine, purchase and sale of documents, and fraud!"
"In view of the defendant's bad attitude of admitting guilt and accepting punishment, which caused extremely bad social impact, causing serious harm to many people and serious circumstances, he was sentenced to a severe sentence."
"Punishment of multiple crimes will be sentenced to 20 years in prison and deprivation of political rights for life."
"The defendant was sentenced to publicly apologize to the civil plaintiff No. 1 and compensate for various expenses of 100,7225 yuan."
"The defendant is sentenced to compensate the civil plaintiff No. 2...99,130 yuan."
"The defendant was sentenced to civil plaintiff No. 3..."
The judge's solemn and loud voice announced Zhang Renjie's final verdict.
Twenty years in prison! A huge amount of financial compensation!
There is also one thing that deprivation of political rights for life!
The so-called deprivation of political rights, according to Article 54 of the Criminal Law, specifically refers to the deprivation of the following rights:
(1) Right to vote and right to be elected;
(II) The right to freedom of speech, publication, assembly, association, parade and demonstration;
(III) The right to hold positions in state organs;
(IV) The right to hold leadership positions in state-owned companies, enterprises, institutions and people's organizations.
On the surface, these regulations seem to be far away from the lives of most people.
Many people even feel that they will never need to exercise these rights in their entire lives.
Um……
Let's give a simple example.
Others will basically have no problems with the Internet, they are free speech.
But if people who are deprived of political rights are in charge, they may be invited to have tea.
Because you don’t have the right to freedom of speech, what right do you have to express your views on certain events online?
And this impact is only a minor deprivation of political rights...
Of course, for Zhang Renjie, it doesn’t matter whether it is deprivation of rights or compensation.
He has been stunned by the "twenty years of fixed-term imprisonment".
When my legs became weak, my body shook.
"Dingling Bang" fell on the dock.
Chen Zhonghan glanced at him in a daze, looked at the ancient well without waves, and then said:
"The above judgment will take effect from the date of trial and will be implemented immediately!"
"If the defendant is dissatisfied with this judgment, he or she may appeal to the higher people's court within fifteen days."
"winter!"
The gavel fell.
Like a heavy hammer, it was smashed down hard.
Zhang Renjie suddenly burst into tears, as if he had lost his parents.