Zheng Yi, as the plaintiff of Longxing Huanyu, began to make his case: "...the industrial, commercial and taxation departments conducted a five-day investigation of Longxing Huanyu Company, but did not find any evidence of tax evasion by the company. In the end, they did not give the company anything."
The explanation was left unanswered. Due to the unwarranted investigation by the industrial and commercial tax department and the freezing of all accounts of Longxing Huanyu Company, it affected the time for Longxing Huanyu Company to recover funds in the futures market, as well as the reputation of Longxing Huanyu Company, resulting in
Longxing Huanyu Company lost 3.986937892 yuan and 5 cents. On behalf of Longxing Huanyu Company, I request the industrial, commercial and taxation departments to compensate Longxing Huanyu Company for all losses. I also request
The court made a fair ruling, giving justice to Longxing Huanyu Company, and allowing all companies in City A to have an environment in which they can operate with peace of mind, because no matter what kind of company they are, if they operate in an environment where they may be suspended for investigation at any time without reason, I
It is impossible for any enterprise to operate with peace of mind..."
When Zheng Yi mentioned that the company had lost more than 3 billion yuan, the press box burst out in exclamation, and the judge hurriedly called for silence.
When it was the turn of the lawyers representing the two departments to speak, the lawyer stood up and said: "President, the Industrial and Commercial Taxation Department of City A entered Longxing Huanyu Company to investigate after receiving a report of tax evasion by Longxing Huanyu Company. The Industrial and Commercial Taxation Department
In order to create a fair and just business environment, we conduct an investigation after receiving a report. This is not only legal, but also reasonable. As for the outcome of the investigation, any situation is possible. Longxing Huanyu Company has not evaded taxes, but it is also obliged to cooperate with law enforcement agencies.
The investigation will also allow law enforcement agencies to clear Longxing Huanyu Company's innocence as soon as possible."
Zheng Yi stood up and said unceremoniously: "The defendant's lawyer is right. It is legal for the industrial and commercial tax law enforcement department to receive the report and launch an investigation. However, the word "reasonable" may not be appropriate. As for the defendant's lawyer's statement that Longxing Huanyu should be returned 'as soon as possible'
The word "as soon as possible" is as unstoppable as a wild dog's fart!"
The defendant's lawyer opposite Zheng Yi was even more angry and his face was livid.
The audience and reporters in the auditorium burst into laughter.
The judge immediately knocked on the table and said: "Please be careful with your words!"
Zheng Yi smiled and said: "President, as a legal worker, everything you say in front of the judge must be well-founded. What the defendant's lawyer said is inconsistent with the facts. He is completely deceiving the presiding judge and contempt of the law!"
The lawyer opposite couldn't help but stand up and said: "Presiding judge, I have something to say!"
After the presiding judge nodded, the defendant's lawyer asked: "Excuse me, the plaintiff's lawyer, is everything you said justified? Then what's wrong with the word 'as soon as possible' that I said?"
Zheng Yi still had a smile on his face and said: "President, the reason why I said the defendant's lawyer's word 'as soon as possible' is bullshit, there is evidence. These are the records of the security department of Julong Building where Long Xing Huanyu is located, the Industrial and Commercial Tax
After the two departments ordered Longxing Huanyu Company to cease operations, they did not enter Longxing Huanyu for more than two hours a day to investigate. This seems to be very different from their words of 'recovering Longxing Huanyu's innocence as soon as possible.'" Zheng Yi said and handed over a copy of Longxing Huanyu.
The records from the security department of the Julong Building where Huanyu was located were handed to the court police and sent to the presiding judge.
The defendant's lawyer was so confused by Zheng Yi that he couldn't wait to defend himself without the consent of the presiding judge: "The plaintiff's lawyer please make it clear before submitting the evidence. The investigation procedure of the law enforcement department is that after the investigation, a summary analysis must be conducted. How long will the investigation last?"
Time cannot prove that the law enforcement agencies did not investigate diligently. Please stop the plaintiff’s lawyers from talking nonsense in front of the law because of ignorance and unqualified rumors.”
Zheng Yi didn't pay attention to the other party's attack, and said naturally: "President, I don't know what the defendant's lawyer just said with your permission? Or is he a public prosecutor who doesn't pay attention to the presiding judge at all?
Don’t you take the law seriously?”
"You..." The defendant's lawyer was at a loss for words. After he said the word "you", he realized that he almost made a mistake again, so he had to stop in a hurry.
Soon he realized that he was confused by Zheng Yi's anger, and took a few deep breaths to calm down.
The presiding judge glanced at the defendant's lawyer and said: "Defendant's lawyer, please pay attention to the order of your speech! Plaintiff's lawyer, the evidence you submitted does not prove that the law enforcement authorities did not restore Long Xing Huanyu's innocence as soon as possible. Do you have any other evidence?"
Zheng Yidao: "President, my client requires the defendant to prove that someone indeed reported Longxing Huanyu Company for tax evasion. Is there any evidence before the investigation?"
The presiding judge looked at the defendant and said: "Maybe the defendant can prove that someone has reported Longxing Huanyu Company?"
The defendant's lawyer stood up and said: "Returning to the presiding judge, the law enforcement department received an anonymous report, so it is impossible to prove that someone actually reported it. As for the evidence before the investigation, if there is evidence, the law enforcement department does not need to investigate further.
"
When it was Zheng Yi's turn, Zheng Yi said calmly: "The fact that the presiding judge and the reporters present at the scene launched an investigation after receiving an anonymous report is a sign of seriousness and responsibility by the law enforcement agencies, but before there is any evidence, they order a company to close down for inspection."
, then although my client has a few subordinates, there are still several hundred people. If each of them makes anonymous calls every day, and the law enforcement agencies shut down the company regardless of whether there is evidence or not, then I am sure that with the power of a few hundred people in Longxing Huanyu, we can
It is possible to anonymously report and shut down all companies of all sizes in city A within one day. Of course, even if the law enforcement departments only visit each company for one or two hours to investigate, I think they will be so busy that they die of exhaustion. Since the defendant cannot
If it proves that someone did report Longxing Huanyu, then we have reason to suspect that a certain leader of the industrial and commercial tax department deliberately made trouble for Longxing Huanyu Company and An Xin wanted to drive Longxing Huanyu to a dead end."
The presiding judge was startled. He didn't expect Zheng Yi to be so bold to raise these things in court. He hurriedly said: "This is a court. Please, the plaintiff's lawyer, please don't say anything without evidence?"
Zheng Yi smiled and glanced sideways at the densely packed cameras behind him, then took out a CD from his briefcase and said, "Presiding Judge, I request the mention of two witnesses."
Soon, the two section chiefs responsible for investigating Long Xing Huanyu were called into the court and stood on the witness stand. Zheng Yi then raised a CD and said: "Presiding Judge, I request that this CD be played in court!"
The court quickly released the CD. The content on the CD was two paragraphs. The first part showed the scene in which the people brought by the two section chiefs ransacked the company like a house raid during an audit.